Picks by situation
The same scores, re-weighted for five kinds of buyer
The short answer
The underlying scores never change. Only the weights move. Under the regulated-and-audited weights, where evidence carries 30 percent and autonomy 25 percent, Microsoft Security Copilot moves to first. Under MSSP weights, where integrations carry 25 percent, Torq leads.
Five buyers, five leaders
| Buyer | First | Second | Third |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lean SOC | Microsoft Security Copilot 6.65 | Torq 6.55 | Mate Security 6.35 |
| Enterprise SOC with SOAR already | Torq 6.90 | Mate Security 6.85 | Simbian 6.35 |
| Microsoft estate | Microsoft Security Copilot 6.55 | Mate Security 6.20 | Torq 5.90 |
| Regulated and audited | Microsoft Security Copilot 6.40 | Mate Security 6.15 | Legion Security 5.90 |
| MSSP | Torq 6.65 | Microsoft Security Copilot 6.40 | Mate Security 6.35 |